KEY CONCEPTS
•
Proven corrosion inhibitors such as benzotriazole and tolyltriazole face increasing regulatory scrutiny, particularly in Europe, because of health and environmental concerns.
•
Replacing established corrosion inhibitors is challenging because alternatives must provide comparable protection at low treat rates while remaining compatible with other lubricant additives, base stocks and demanding operating conditions.
•
The industry is exploring new azole-free, biobased and other alternative technologies, but no single chemistry is likely to replace conventional inhibitors across all lubricant applications.
The widely used class of heterocyclic chemicals for copper alloy corrosion and rust inhibition are facing regulatory pressure. As it stands, industries rely on a small, select number of corrosion inhibitors derived from di- and triazole cores. These inhibitors have proven to be highly effective at low treat rates and have minimal impact on antiwear systems.
However, the potential classification changes due to possible reproductive toxicity and endocrine disruption are under increasing scrutiny. This may necessitate the development of new chemicals or affect the supply of certain formulations.
The lubricants industry has an active involvement in studies and is attempting to adapt to the evolving regulatory landscape. However, there is a need for commitment to finding alternatives and ensuring the continued efficacy of lubricant additives.
These corrosion inhibitors are crucial for maintaining the performance and longevity of mechanical components. They are sparingly oil-soluble and partition to the surface, providing effective protection.
For decades, a small group of highly effective corrosion inhibitor formulations has provided reliable protection across a wide range of lubricant applications. As the regulatory environment evolves, the challenge for lubricant formulators goes beyond identifying other molecules that inhibit copper corrosion. Alternatives must deliver comparable performance at low treat rates, coexist effectively with antiwear and extreme pressure (EP) additives, and meet evolving regulatory requirements, all while maintaining the expected level of protection.
STLE member Dr. Brian Casey, senior manager of research and development, Vanderbilt Chemicals LLC, says, "The costs associated with chemical regulation present a significant hurdle to innovation. While necessary to ensure human and environmental safety, registration of new chemistries is an expensive and resource-intensive expenditure. The chemical industry as a whole has the technical prowess to develop "next-gen" additives that are effective and safe. However, truly innovative and transformative technologies are frequently set aside due to the cost of registration."
So the core issue is: How does an industry preserve proven corrosion protection as regulatory requirements evolve
(see Relevant Regulatory Entities and Frameworks)?
Relevant regulatory entities and frameworks
1.
European Chemicals Agency (ECHA)/EU REACH. ECHA administers major elements of REACH, the EU framework for the registration, evaluation, authorization and restriction of chemicals, including substances used as corrosion inhibitors. Of particular concern to the lubricants industry are restrictions on some substances and authorization requirements for substances of very high concern (SVHCs), both of which can drive the search for alternatives.
2.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)/Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA). In the U.S., industrial chemicals used in lubricants and corrosion inhibitors fall under EPA oversight through TSCA. If evaluation identifies an unreasonable risk, EPA has authority to impose requirements or restrictions covering manufacturing, processing, use, distribution and disposal.
3.
UK Health and Safety Executive (HSE)/UK REACH. Great Britain established its own UK REACH system following its departure from the EU, with HSE serving as the primary regulatory agency. The system requires manufacturers and importers to identify and manage chemical risks and provides mechanisms for authorization and restriction of substances of very high concern.
4.
Environment and Climate Change Canada/Health Canada – CEPA. Canada addresses potentially harmful chemicals primarily through the Canadian Environmental Protection Act (CEPA) and its Chemicals Management Plan. Substances that pose risks to human health or the environment may face risk management measures affecting their manufacture, import or use, including their use in industrial formulations.
Proven corrosion inhibitors: The current market
The current corrosion inhibitor market includes several formulations, some of which have been around for decades.
•
Triazoles. They are the most commonly used, especially for copper and copper alloys. Benzotriazole (BTA) and tolyltriazole (TTA) are the most familiar, along with alkylated and modified versions of both. Derivatives provide formulators with some flexibility because of solubility or compatibility with other components in the formulation.
•
Thiadiazoles. These include dimercaptothiadiazole (DMTD) derivatives. This class is a frequent component of lubricant and metalworking formulations, partly since they provide more than corrosion protection. Depending on the formulation, they may add antiwear or EP performance.
•
Mercaptobenzothiazoles and related BTAs. 2-Mercaptobenzothiazole (MBT) and derivatives can be used for copper and copper alloy protection.
These corrosion inhibitors deliver proven performance and are well known by formulators who have considerable experience working with them. Even so, long-term use does not insulate these chemicals from evolving regulations. As regulators place greater emphasis on environmental persistence, mobility and potential health effects, some of the most trusted corrosion inhibitors are receiving renewed scrutiny.
Regulatory pressure
Increased regulatory scrutiny is taking place more in Europe than the U.S. In particular, BTA and TTA have been targeted because of concerns such as persistence, mobility and possible effects on human health and/or the environment.
Dr. Federico Grillo, senior scientific officer (surface science), XPS Facility Manager School of Chemistry, University of St Andrews, UK, observes, "The main factors driving regulatory screening are essentially environmental persistence, bioaccumulation in waters and on the ground and consequential effects on the environment. Because some corrosion inhibitors have been used for decades across multiple industrial applications, regulatory agencies potentially have access to a growing body of data that can support long-term assessments. Scrutiny also focuses on monitoring exposure, transport and on the environmental fate of these substances, which means how they distribute across environmental compartments, how readily they degrade and whether they can migrate through water systems. All of these factors contribute to long-term environmental exposure."
Per Grillo, the extensive review of BTA under the European Union (EU) REACH framework reflects scrutiny toward evaluating the full environmental lifecycle of chemical substances. REACH (Registration, Evaluation, Authorisation and Restriction of Chemicals) is the EU's regulatory framework for assessing and managing the risks that chemicals may pose to human health and the environment. "This increased scrutiny is likely to influence future research and development by encouraging the design of additive technologies that provide the same level of corrosion protection while demonstrating improved environmental profiles, lower persistence and reduced long-term environmental impact," he says. "Ultimately, regulatory expectations are pushing innovation toward solutions that balance performance, durability and sustainability."
Under EU REACH, regulators are evaluating these substances to determine whether additional classification or regulatory action is necessary. However, it's important to note that the situation is evolving, and the regulatory status for these substances varies.
STLE member Daniel Vargo, senior research chemist, Functional Products Inc., says, "I think that REACH and the Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA) regulatory restrictions in Europe and North America are having the greatest influence and forcing the phase-out of traditional, well-proven chemistries. This includes certain borates, biocides and persistent fluorinated compounds (PFAS). These restrictions will become tighter in the future."
Vargo adds, "I am seeing stricter limits on airborne emissions and workplace air quality. Low-volatile organic compound (VOC) or even water-based ferrous corrosion preventatives that minimize hazardous vapor exposure will become more sought after in the lubricants market. Along with that I am seeing a greater need for safe anti-mist additives."
Another area he cites is sulfated ash, phosphorus and sulfur (SAPS) in lubricants. "This is more of a concern with fluid disposal," he clarifies. "These components are of importance in meeting top-tier performance requirements."
For lubricant formulators, distributors and end-users, none of this necessarily means these proven chemistries are going away. Rather it indicates that regulatory status and the availability of alternatives are increasingly becoming considerations for choosing a corrosion inhibitor.
Grillo says, "Regulators pay particular attention to corrosion inhibitors derived from BTA and related chemistries because of concerns regarding environmental persistence, mobility and potential long-term effects mainly on aquatic ecosystems. In Europe, BTA underwent an extensive regulatory evaluation by the EU European Chemicals Agency, ECHA (the equivalent of U.S. Environmental Protection Agency [EPA]), over much of the past decade. This evaluation covered all environmental endpoints (physico-chemical data, ecotoxicity data, exposure, fate and behavior) both
in vivo and
in vitro. Broadly speaking, the outcomes confirmed the concerns, leading to stronger regulation of the uses of the molecule. Similar outcomes are expected for other di- and triazole based compounds."
Benzotriazoles
BTA is currently under REACH scrutiny. For 1H-benzotriazole, CAS 95-14-7—Germany has completed a Risk Management Option Analysis (RMOA). The German REACH/CLP (classification, labeling and packaging) initial concerns include persistence and mobility for lubricants and greases, metalworking fluids, engine coolants, brake fluids and surface-treatment applications. The RMOA has been finalized, with CLH (harmonized classification and labeling) identified as the suggested follow-up.
There are many BTA compounds, and their REACH status is not interchangeable. Some BTA derivatives are already on the REACH Candidate List of Substances of Very High Concern (SVHCs). For example, UV-329, a substituted BTA used primarily as a UV stabilizer, was added to the Candidate List in January 2024 because of its very persistent and very bioaccumulative (vPvB) properties. Bumetrizole (UV-326) was added for the same reason. In February 2026, ECHA included UV-329 in its draft 13th recommendation of substances for possible inclusion in REACH Annex XIV, the Authorisation List. However, none of this means that BTA corrosion inhibitor (CAS 95-14-7) is an SVHC.
Under REACH generally, manufacturers or importers handling more than 1 tonne/year must register substances and provide information on properties, uses, hazards and risk management (1 metric tonne equals about 1.102 U.S. tons). It's important to remember that registration is not the same as restriction or prohibition.
The German RMOA is particularly significant evidence of the direction regulators are moving toward: evaluating whether additional regulatory risk management measures are warranted.
Tolyltriazoles
ECHA identifies methyl-1H-benzotriazole/TTA as a REACH-registered substance that is subject to regulatory assessment. Germany completed an RMOA for TTA and several related substances. The initial concerns noted are persistence and mobility. Known uses specifically include functional fluids, lubricants and greases, surface-treatment agents and metalworking fluids. This German RMOA lists two suggested follow-up actions for TTA:
•
SVHC identification
•
CLH (harmonized classification and labeling)
That's notably different from BTA (CAS 95-14-7). Its German RMOA also identifies persistence and mobility as concerns with suggested follow-up as CLH, while the TTA assessment explicitly includes possible SVHC identification. SVHC identification does not mean TTA has been designated an SVHC. It means the German authority concluded that pursuing the SVHC identification process is an appropriate regulatory option.
Germany didn't evaluate only TTA. Its RMOA also considered several closely related substances, including sodium methylbenzotriazole (CAS 64665-57-2), potassium methylbenzotriazole, 6-methylbenzotriazole and a reaction mass containing methylbenzotriazoles. Given this, lubricant formulators can't necessarily assume that just moving from one commercially used form of TTA to a closely related TTA salt will avoid future regulatory scrutiny.
The search for alternatives
Casey notes that replacing corrosion inhibitors is rarely a one-for-one substitution. "As with other additive classes (antioxidants, friction modifiers, antiwear agents, etc.), the performance profiles of corrosion inhibitors are highly formulation-dependent," he says. "As a result, maintaining performance while eliminating regulatory issues presents a significant challenge to formulators. Additive-additive interactions within a given formulation are numerous and complex. Even seemingly straightforward substitutions require empirical data to establish no-harm and performance equivalency."
A copper inhibitor has to do much more than perform well in an isolated copper corrosion test. It may have to coexist with:
•
Antiwear and EP additives, particularly sulfur-containing and phosphorus-containing chemistries
•
Antioxidants and detergents
•
Different base stocks and polarity levels
•
Ferrous-metal rust inhibitors
•
Seals and other materials
•
High temperatures and long drain intervals
In addition, the inhibitor can't crowd out the surface at the expense of antiwear/EP additives. This is why established triazole chemistries are so difficult to replace; their combination of effectiveness, low treat rate, metal deactivation and formulation compatibility has been refined over decades. This means lubricant-specific replacements still need to clear a demanding performance and compatibility hurdle.
"All performance additives have a certain degree of affinity for the metal surface," Vargo explains. "Antiwear, EP and friction modifiers compete with a corrosion inhibitor for the metal surface. Corrosion inhibitors get caught up in this competition with other additives for the surface. A judicious selection and determination of the optimum treat level for each component needs to be addressed by the formulator. The choice of performance beyond corrosion protection depends on what is desired by the customer."
Alternatives to BTA
Grillo notes, "For the lubricant industry, depending on the product, possible reformulation could be necessary, with implications including additional testing, enhanced environmental assessment obligations and potentially the identification of alternative technologies. In the extreme, this could lead to an overall product reformulation. The primary challenge will be maintaining the performance and reliability that these corrosion inhibitors provide, thus satisfying the customer base, while meeting evolving regulatory expectations and sustainability objectives."
Common alternatives to BTA for copper and yellow metal corrosion inhibition include TTA and sodium TTA for industrial water systems, MBT for enhanced film strength, 1,2,4-Triazole for electronics, and biobased options like L-cysteine or salicylaldoxime for artifact conservation.
Industrial and aqueous systems
•
TTA/sodium TTA. Features an extra methyl group that provides better thermal stability and higher resistance to chlorine and oxidizing biocides than BTA.
•
Mercaptobenzothiazole (MBT). Is often blended with TTA to create a tougher, more synergistic barrier film on copper alloys.
•
Sodium silicate/molybdates. These are inorganic alternatives used in mild water systems or closed loops where azoles are restricted.
Specialty and ecofriendly alternatives
•
1,2,4-Triazole (TAZ). This is frequently included in electronic chemical mechanical planarization (CMP) and specific fluid formulas.
•
L-cysteine. This is a non-toxic, biobased amino acid alternative studied extensively for stabilizing archaeological bronze and copper against active corrosion.
•
Salicylaldoxime. This is used as an organic anti-tarnish alternative in severe, humid environments for copper and bronze materials.
While these alternatives expand the options available to formulators, choosing a replacement is not a matter of substituting one inhibitor for another. Azole-based inhibitors, in particular, can present challenges under certain operating conditions.
•
Halogen resistance. Traditional azoles degrade quickly when exposed to oxidizing biocides like chlorine or bromine used for disinfection in cooling towers.
•
Environmental regulations. Azoles can contribute to aquatic toxicity and increased levels of halogenated organic compounds (AOX) in industrial plant discharges.
•
Preventing system degradation. High usage of oxidizers destroys standard azole films, causing copper to corrode and, because of galvanic action, pit nearby mild steel parts.
Each chemistry brings its own performance characteristics, application limitations and environmental considerations.
Azole-free copper corrosion inhibitors
Azole-free copper corrosion inhibitors are an increasingly important area of development. BTA, TTA and their derivatives have been difficult to replace because they are exceptionally effective on copper at relatively low concentrations. They adhere strongly to copper and form a protective surface complex. In lubricants, that protection also helps suppress copper-catalyzed oxidation.
There isn't one established replacement class that has emerged as the successor to BTA/TTA. Rather, research has explored several approaches, including sulfur-containing organic compounds, amine- and carboxylate-based inhibitors, phosphorus-containing compounds, surfactant/film-forming chemistries and various non-azole organic molecules capable of adsorbing or binding to copper.
One especially interesting route is thiadiazole chemistry. Thiadiazoles can be effective copper/yellow metal passivators, particularly in lubricant systems containing active sulfur
(see Copper Passivators: Raising an Issue About Regulation). Depending on the context, thiadiazoles cannot always be described as "azole-free."
Copper passivators: Raising an issue about regulation
Paul Bessette, vice president of research and development for Kano Laboratories LLC, says that the need for regulating certain corrosion inhibitors isn't straightforward. Based on extensive formulating experience, he has come to believe that all technology tends to have a duality that is beneficial, but not without a downside. He uses the example of metal passivators.
"Copper and its alloys have a chemical propensity to corrode in the presence of sulfur-based EP additives," he says. "As a result, formulators will incorporate a small amount of a copper passivator to protect the surface of the copper. Based on research I conducted many years ago, there is a much more subtle reason to use copper passivators in a wide range of oils and greases."
To demonstrate this, at one time he placed a highly polished strip of copper into a beaker of oil containing a synthetic fluid. After a fixed amount of time, he analyzed the fluid for the presence of dissolved copper by ion-coupled emission spectroscopy. This analytical technique was able to detect certain elements in the parts per billion (PPB) range.
"Since copper is catalytic for the thermo-oxidative degradation of lubricants especially at elevated temperatures, I determined then that metal passivators are a viable additive to use for even synthetic lubricants to promote long-term stability against the ravages of oxygen and heat," he adds. "One particular area where this strategy is effective pertains to sintered metal bearings. These bearings are considerably more economical than rolling element bearings but they are more difficult to lubricate; sintered bearings are porous and provide no opportunity for the formation of an elastohydrodynamic film (EHD). With a high surface-to-volume ratio, lubricants are prone to rapid catalytic degradation. This is where yellow metal copper passivators help." For Bessette, this is also where the frustration of regulation comes in.
"The hue and cry from some quarters is that chemicals resist degradation and that is a valid observation," he observes. "However, as a tribologist that is exactly the mission I've been on for the last 50 years. If a lubricant is designed to last the entire service life, the application is successful, fewer raw materials are required, economic benefits are realized and the best environmental stewardship results.
"The safety data sheet (SDS) for my preferred yellow metal passivators (YMP) states that it is very toxic to aquatic life with an LC50 of 1.3 milligrams/liter to
Danio rerio. (LC50 is the concentration of a substance in air or water that causes death in 50% of a test population during a specified exposure period.
Danio rerio is the scientific name for the zebrafish, a small freshwater fish commonly used in toxicology and environmental testing.) At my firm we use that same yellow metal passivator at 0.3% in synthetic hydrocarbon gear oils, and I cannot fathom how an industrial gearbox fluid will find its way into the ocean to endanger a zebrafish."
He concludes, "The best activism occurs when the subject matter is understood."
There is an important distinction between BTA-free and azole-free. A product described as BTA-free may still contain another azole, such as a thiadiazole, imidazole or other heterocyclic chemistry. A genuinely azole-free inhibitor eliminates the azole completely.
True non-azole technologies
For industrial water-treatment applications, companies are already introducing products explicitly marketed as
azole-free/non-azole copper corrosion inhibitors. The Cooling Technology Institute's 2026 conference program describes research on a "true non-azole solution" for industrial recirculating systems. The technology is described as providing copper corrosion protection comparable to BTAs while using biodegradable, non-toxic chemistry. The research includes surface analysis of the passivation mechanism and industrial field trials.
1 While this particular chemistry can't be transferred to lubricants because the formulation environment is radically different, it demonstrates that true non-azole copper passivation is technologically feasible.
Vargo adds, "The performance of a corrosion inhibitor can change with different base fluids as it is the major component in a formulation. The base fluid plays an important part especially for environmentally acceptable lubricant (EAL) or Ecolabel applications. The common base fluids for these applications are triglyceride oils, synthetic esters, polyalkylene glycols (PAGs) or, to a lesser extent, certain low viscosity polyalphaolefins (PAOs)."
Vargo continues: "Each of these fluids have their own drawbacks, such as oxidative and hydrolytic stability as well as polarity and additive solubility. Oil-based fluids require component compatibility far different from aqueous based systems. The use of a certain corrosion inhibitor must be tested preferably in a suitable matrix with the other additives present to determine the optimum level of each component."
Vargo has observed that there is greater interest in the area of multifunctional additives. "Cost is typically the top concern," he says. "If the right additive is selected to provide effective corrosion inhibition and antiwear, for example, this is certainly a plus, and it can reduce the formulation cost. As with any additive, it must be balanced with environmental objectives."
Future regulation and substitution
As corrosion inhibitor formulations and regulatory expectations continue to evolve, communication between industry and regulators will become increasingly important. Grillo emphasizes that the most productive path forward is not to treat performance, innovation and regulatory compliance as competing priorities.
He says, "Effective collaboration starts with transparency, early engagement and scientific dialogue. Companies and regulators have different yet ultimately complementary objectives. Companies need to develop innovative products that meet customer needs and remain commercially viable, while regulators are responsible for ensuring that marketed products meet appropriate health, safety and environmental protection standards. These objectives should not be viewed as conflicting.
"The most effective collaborations occur when both parties recognize that innovation and safety are mutually dependent rather than mutually exclusive. Companies should share robust data on product performance, exposure scenarios, environmental fate and potential hazards, while regulators should provide clear guidance on data expectations and risk assessment criteria."
Grillo adds, "Maintaining an open and constructive dialogue throughout the product lifecycle ought to help in identifying early potential concerns, support better regulatory decision making and ultimately lead to safer and more sustainable products reaching the market."
Again, it's important to factor in the distinction between technical alternatives and regulatory alternatives. For example, TTA is an obvious technical alternative to BTA, but not a viable regulatory alternative. This is because, as previously mentioned, TTA itself is receiving European regulatory scrutiny. Similarly, moving from BTA to another closely related persistent azole may solve the corrosion problem without necessarily solving the environmental/regulatory problem. Following are some possible regulatory alternatives.
Regulatory-driven BTA alternatives
•
Indazole and benzimidazole. These are probably the most directly relevant near-term alternatives. A new 2026
Corrosion Science study compares BTA and TTA directly with indazole and benzimidazole in glycol-based fluids, specifically describing the research as motivated by increasing regulatory constraints on conventional inhibitors.
2
•
Other azoles/heterocycles. Imidazoles, mercapto-imidazoles, thiazoles, thiadiazoles and tetrazoles have all demonstrated copper corrosion inhibition. In some environments, 2-mercaptobenzimidazole has shown stronger inhibition than BTA.
•
Biobased/organic inhibitors. This is the more radical non-azole choice. One comparative study found a biobased treatment more effective than BTA for chloride-corroded copper under its particular test conditions. While that's promising evidence, the application did not specifically pertain to lubricants.
3
•
Silicates and other inorganic systems. These are potentially useful in aqueous systems, although their applicability to lubricants is much more limited. Recent work involves investigating silicate-based copper protection specifically as a greener alternative to conventional inhibitor packages.
Biobased green alternatives to BTA/TTA
Some biobased/green inhibitors currently being researched include:
•
Amino acids and amino acid derivatives. Methionine, cysteine, histidine, aspartic acid and related compounds have been studied as biodegradable corrosion inhibitors. Their functional groups can interact with metal surfaces and form protective films; however, performance varies considerably by formulation and application.
•
Polyaspartates. Sodium polyaspartate (NaPASP) is particularly interesting because it is a biodegradable polymer derived from aspartic acid. In recent research specifically looking for green alternatives to azoles in cooling towers, NaPASP was the most promising commercially available substance tested, although its inhibition efficiency was still about 10 percentage points below the BTA/TTA mixture under the particular test conditions.
4
•
Tannins/tannic acid and other plant polyphenols. These renewable compounds are among the most widely investigated classes of plant-derived corrosion inhibitors. Tannins, flavonoids and other polyphenols can interact with metal surfaces and form protective layers. Much of the research concerns metals and environments other than the copper protection applications where BTA and TTA traditionally excel.
•
Biomass-derived carbon dots (BCDs). Synthesized from natural precursors, these nanoparticles exhibit copper corrosion inhibition efficiencies often greater than 90%. They form a dense, physical barrier layer combined with strong chemical adsorption.
"In my experience, reclassifications of existing chemistries to include CMR (carcinogenic, mutagenic, reprotoxic) risks are major technical and market disruptors," Casey advises. "When faced with carrying those risks on the final labels, reformulation to an alternative product is usually the ultimate goal."
He adds, "New additives specifically designed to address problematic functional groups represent the most compelling and comprehensive replacements. For example, increasing the molecular weight of a TTA-based or BTA-based additive through chemical modification potentially can reduce the bioavailability. However, as molecular weight increases, additive activity typically decreases requiring higher treat rates to maintain performance. Linking two additives (e.g., a corrosion inhibitor and an antioxidant) together is a strategy to simultaneously increase the molecular weight and expand the performance profile. Alternative additives need to strike a balance between chemistry and performance to be considered as viable solutions."
Working with academia
Collaboration with academia can provide another important way to address the technical and regulatory challenges surrounding corrosion inhibitors. Grillo points to industry-academic partnerships as a way to combine commercial expertise with longer-term scientific research and independent data generation.
"One point worth highlighting is the value of collaboration between industry and academia," Grillo says. "While companies are often focused on delivering commercial products within relatively short development timelines, academic institutions can investigate longer-term scientific questions that may not fit within a typical industrial project cycle. These partnerships can be particularly valuable when addressing emerging regulatory concerns, as they allow for the generation of independent scientific data, the exploration of novel technologies and a deeper understanding of the environmental and health implications of chemical substances."
Grillo continues, "From an industry perspective, such collaborations can also provide additional benefits, including access to specialized expertise, increased visibility within the scientific community and, in some jurisdictions, research incentives or tax-relief programs that support innovation activities.
"As regulatory expectations continue to evolve, stronger collaboration among industry, academia and regulatory bodies will be increasingly important to develop solutions that are both scientifically robust and commercially viable."
Preparing for a changing corrosion inhibitor landscape
Per Casey, chemical regulation and sustainability directives will be significant drivers for innovation going forward. "It is no longer sufficient for new additives to provide superior performance compared to existing options," he says. "For success in the long term, a new technology must not only meet the performance requirements of end-users but also provide a clear regulatory outlook into the future."
There are three primary ways that stakeholders can prepare for the likelihood of a tighter regulatory landscape:
•
Industry participation in regulatory studies
•
Collaboration among additive suppliers, lubricant formulators and regulators
•
Maintaining compliance while continuing to innovate
Grillo concludes, "Companies should integrate regulatory foresight into product development rather than treating compliance as a checklist. Monitoring emerging regulatory trends allows organizations to identify potential risks before they become business constraints."
Grillo suggests an innovation focus on developing additives that deliver equivalent or improved performance with a friendlier environmental and toxicological profile. Artificial intelligence (AI), digital modeling, predictive toxicology and data-driven formulation approaches will accelerate this process.
"Because lubricant performance requirements vary significantly across applications, there is unlikely to be a single replacement technology suitable for every formulation. A portfolio of solutions will probably be required," he says.
Vargo believes that, with the development and increased interest in electric vehicles (EVs), new copper corrosion inhibitors may need to be developed for the lubricant system. "The details of electric motor design will have a large impact on the lubricant system that will be needed," he says. "Copper will be used extensively for the motor since it has high electrical conductivity. The lubricant must provide protection from copper corrosion, effective cooling and have the necessary dielectric properties along with many other properties. Additionally, the lubricant must not degrade and need to be changed over the life of the EV."
Vargo notes that formulators are replacing petroleum oils with renewable synthetic esters, dicarboxylic acid amine complexes and vegetable oils that offer high biodegradability and low skin irritation. "Multi-metal compatibility is achieved using ashless, non-hazardous organic acid technologies rather than toxic heavy metals or chlorinated paraffins," he says, concluding, "Amino acids are a promising component that can be used as a safe corrosion inhibitor in a properly formulated lubricant. I think that there is a shortage of research being done with nanotechnology-based corrosion inhibitors. Many nano-based corrosion inhibitors offer efficient and good corrosion protection, but changes in temperature and pH can affect their performance and need to be studied further."
Vargo says these questions regarding alternative formulations still need to be answered:
•
Are they cost-effective?
•
What performance level can be expected?
•
What are the environmental implications?
REFERENCES
1.
https://assets.speakcdn.com/assets/2793/cti_annual_conference_news-2026.pdf
2.
Boonen, L., Choukroun, D., Napal Azcona, I., Nappini, S., Magnano, E., Cornelus, J. and Breugelmans, T. (2026), "Corrosion inhibition of copper in glycol-based heat transfer fluids: A comparative gravimetric and electrochemical study,"
Corrosion Science,
265, 113822. DOI: 10.1016/j.corsci.2026.113822. Available at
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0010938X26002313.
3.
Albini, M., Letardi, P., Mathys, L., Brambilla, L., Schröter, J., Junier, P. and Joseph, E. (2018), "Comparison of a bio-based corrosion inhibitor versus benzotriazole on corroded copper surfaces,"
Corrosion Science,
143, pp. 84-92. DOI: 10.1016/j.corsci.2018.08.020. Available at
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0010938X18304591.
4.
Radwan, M. (2026),
Investigating Green Alternatives to Azoles for Inhibiting Copper Corrosion in Cooling Towers, Department of Chemical Engineering, McGill University.
Jeanna Van Rensselar heads her own communication/public relations firm, Smart PR Communications, in Naperville, Ill. You can reach her at jeanna@smartprcommunications.com.